Skip to content
Skip to Content

We Were Terrified of Surrogacy. Then We Met Melissa.

Rachel and Matt with Melissa, their surrogate
Rachel, Matt and Melissa, our VIP.

By the time we turned to surrogacy, we were seven years all-in on IVF.

We entered the surrogacy process as the walking wounded. In the midst of battling a “futile” IVF prognosis, my world shattered when I suddenly lost my dad. Then, timed to the anniversary of his passing, came the miscarriage.

After three unsuccessful attempts, we made a hard, strategic choice. We could not keep risking our most precious embryos. We decided to try two more times and then, if needed, pivot to surrogacy. While I hoped that strategy would just be a backup plan, when it came to fruition, I was immersed in grief. Yet, still, I moved forward.

There was urgency to get on the one-year waitlist, which ended up being two brutally long years. During the wait, the sheer distance between me and my baby concerned me. But my soul was focused on bringing this child into the world, no matter the path.

The Magic of Mutual Connection

Finally, we were introduced to Melissa and her husband. Their compassion and pure intentions put us at ease right away. Then came an early miscommunication over the contract that turned awkward fast, due to whispers down the lane with the surrogacy agency. When we finally got on the phone, just the four of us, the confusion cleared within minutes. We were relieved to realize we were actually on the same page all along. And we made a pact: We would always speak directly about any concerns and would prioritize each other’s comfort. We agreed that with the stakes of pregnancy, being direct was a necessity.

When we met in person months later, we hugged, took a picture and just started walking. New York City became our playground. We laughed at the shenanigans we observed while people-watching in the park and getting caught in the background of YouTube pranks. We shared our love of food and culture.

And yes, there were awkward silences. But we acknowledged and laughed about them with deep appreciation for the surreal nature of the situation: Here we are, strangers eating dinner, and oh, by the way, you are about to carry my baby.

The Surrogate Is a Very Important Person (VIP)

Over breakfast, we casually asked, “How was the flight?” and were surprised by the answer.

Even though we paid for premium agency service, Melissa’s comfort was overlooked until we, the parents, stepped in. Seemingly small things, like a senseless layover and a middle seat right before a full day of medical testing, made clear to us that the stress of meeting strangers, leaving her children and being physically examined was not considered to be a priority compared to profit-protecting shortcuts. We had already gone above the default protocol to book accommodations two days early, just as I would have wanted, so she could settle in. After learning about the stressful travel, we vowed not to make any assumptions.

Our philosophy was simple: Only VIP treatment for our Very Important Person.

The Dream Team

Then came transfer day. That is when it really hit us: Melissa is about to receive our precious embryo. Wow.

Before the procedure, the doctor paused. He asked if we were sharing the sex of the baby. We hadn’t thought about it before. But at that moment, my husband and I locked eyes, and the answer was immediate: “Yes.”

She was about to carry our daughter. She was in the circle of trust.

That trust let us be vulnerable. Early on, we shared our full history with Melissa. We didn’t hide our pain and also wanted to be mindful not to overwhelm her with it. She and her husband leaned in. They understood she was carrying a baby that was prayed for, dreamt about, worked for and waited for by a family that was still healing. And she was there to soften that pain.

Advocacy Is a Love Language

With our team approach, we emphasized mutual respect and wellbeing. This turned out to be even more critical than we all expected. When the agency refused to honor medical necessities and contractual obligations, we relentlessly advocated for a hospital transfer and finally achieved it at 34 weeks’ gestation. Together, we shielded each other from undue stress and focused on mutual advocacy to protect both Melissa and our baby. With the realities of pregnancy, the stakes are too high to accept anything but the highest levels of care.

The Moment We Both Waited For

Finally, we were in the hospital. It was happening. We were bedside with Melissa, witnessing the birth of our child. Amid the intensity of it all, I told Melissa, “I love you.” She said it right back.

When we saw our daughter, I sobbed immediately while holding out my hand for her, cutting the cord and pulling her close.

Through the tears, I whispered the words I’d been holding for seven years: “We prayed for you. We dreamt of you.”

And from the bed, watching us finally hold the baby she had protected for nine months, Melissa said, warmly: “I’m so happy for you guys.”

The moment we had been waiting for…was the same moment.

What led us to that delivery room was not luck. It was love. It was dedication, respect, compassion, care and protection. The distance I’d worried about closed not through physical proximity, but through the kind of devotion that pulls two families into a dream team.

We never thought we’d say we love our surrogate and her husband like family. But we do. This victory wasn’t just ours; it was theirs, too.

With love, our baby was carried by all of us.

The gift of life has bound us together forever.